Who Pays to Keep America Uninformed?

Empty classroom desks, representing concerns about civic education and the influence of funded messaging
who pays to shape what we know

In Sea-Change (2001), I worried about Americans losing their understanding of our Republic. In Well, Now We Know, I returned to that concern. Twenty-five years later, the question is no longer simply what happened? It’s who is paying to shape what we know?

The educational numbers are grim. In the 2022 National Assessment of Educational Progress, just 22 percent of eighth-graders reached the assessment’s Proficient standard in civics. That is not proof of a conspiracy, and the percentage was not significantly different from 1998. But it is ample reason to worry about civic knowledge.

Follow the money

The Pulitzer Center openly names Meta as the lead supporter of its 1619 Project Education Network. Other supporters include Open Society Foundations, Rockefeller Brothers Fund, and the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation. The project has faced serious historical criticism, and its backers are financing material intended for classrooms. That establishes influence and invites scrutiny; it does not establish that these donors set out to make children ignorant.

We have stronger evidence of intentional public deception elsewhere. In Alabama’s 2017 Senate race, an operation known as Project Birmingham used deceptive online tactics; reporting connected $100,000 of its funding to an organization supported by Reid Hoffman. Hoffman said he did not know about the tactics and apologized.

In 2024 the Justice Department alleged that employees of Russian state broadcaster RT covertly directed approximately $9.7 million through a U.S. content company to influence Americans. The indictment remains an allegation, not a conviction. Yet the alleged machinery, shell companies, concealed sponsors and disguised messaging, is precisely why transparency matters.

An inconvenient distinction

Funding controversial teaching is not the same thing as funding deliberate deception. We should challenge both curriculum claims and propaganda with evidence, rather than pretend we have uncovered one grand puppet master.

A Republic cannot govern itself on slogans, selective history, or manufactured outrage. We ought to demand rigorous civics, transparent donors, and the freedom to question every fashionable certainty. Teach children how to think, and disclose who’s paying to tell them what to think.

Sources: NAEP Civics; Pulitzer Center donor disclosure; U.S. Department of Justice indictment; Washington Post investigation of Project Birmingham.

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail
Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.